12H Free Proof
Baseball Pins
● Free artwork design & Unlimited revisions
● 24-Hour Rush Production & Free Delivery
● 12-Hour Free Artwork Proof
● 24-Hour Rush Production & Free Delivery
● 12-Hour Free Artwork Proof
Excellent
14,685 reviews on
On-Time Delivery
24/7 Live Chat Support
No Minimum Qty
Popular Baseball Pins
Fast production
Rush Baseball Pins
• 24-Hour quick production
• Clean, polished finish
• Ready-made mold inventory
• Zero setup charges
• Clean, polished finish
• Ready-made mold inventory
• Zero setup charges
Fast production
Printed Baseball Pins
• Speedy production and delivery
• Even, flat surface
• Ideal for intricate artwork
• Long-lasting and budget-friendly
• Even, flat surface
• Ideal for intricate artwork
• Long-lasting and budget-friendly
Fast production
Soft Enamel Baseball Pins
• Vivid colors and fine detail
• Raised, dimensional feel
• Optional add-on upgrades
• Great keepsake value
• Raised, dimensional feel
• Optional add-on upgrades
• Great keepsake value
Available Upgrades
Choose from 9 different upgrade features for your baseball pins and make your design stand out even more.
Sliders Baseball Pins
Bobble Heads Baseball Pins
Spinners Baseball Pins
Danglers Baseball Pins
Blinking Lights Baseball Pins
Glitter Baseball Pins
Transparent Color Baseball Pins
Glow In The Dark Baseball Pins
Rhinestone Baseball Pins
Baseball Pins For Every Occasion
Team Pride
Unify your squad with custom designs made exclusively for your team. Add your logo, mascot, or rally cry, and every player can sport the same mark on bags, hats, or jerseys.
Campus Life
Show off your school pride with custom baseball pins — ideal for varsity teams and graduating class mementos that capture your best baseball moments on campus.
Community Events
From local little league tournaments and neighborhood baseball camps to charity exhibition games, our pins help bring your community together around the diamond.
Personal Collection
Design baseball pins featuring your favorite player numbers, ballpark memories, or game-day slogans — build a one-of-a-kind collection that tells your own baseball story.
Frequently Asked Questions
[Baseball Pins] What are baseball pins?
[Turnaround Time] How quickly will my baseball pins arrive?
[Attachments] What attachment styles are available for baseball pins?
[Artwork] What if I only have an idea and no artwork — can I still get custom baseball pins?
[Artwork Formats] What file types do you accept for baseball pin artwork?
[Options] What custom features can I add to my baseball pins?
14K+ 5-star ratings
10 years Collecting Reviews
5
Out of 5.0
(14258) (363) (38) (5) (21)
5
Out of 5.0 Overall Rating
14,000+ reviews
11-02-26
Very Happy With Order / Product. Jean is always very helpful at working to ensure customer gets exactly what they desire with no unpleasant surprises. Repeat customer each year and will continue to be. Thank you
11-02-26
Great fast service and shipping
11-01-26
Thank you Grace. This is my second time ordering and I am even more pleased this time around. Thank you! They are mainly as requested, good price, nice finish. A few have some rough edges but, I am overall satisfied with my purchase.
10-31-26
Polaris was great to work with. This is the second product that we have worked on together with a thrid almost completed. We have done a Police Explorer Patch, now badge, and last will be the challenge coin. Polaris took the time to listen to all of my concerns and work with the factory to try and solve the concern. I will continue to shop with Polaris as well as GS-JJ as their quality, prices, and customer service are top of the line. Thank you
10-31-26
Lonni provided excellent customer service!
10-31-26
Lonni was great. Thankful for a helpful and speedy team! The pins I received look great.
10-30-26
Leah at GS-JJ has been consistently accommodating and supportive. Our order arrived on time, and she followed up to make sure everything was received and that we were satisfied. We truly appreciate her attentive service and look forward to working with her on future projects. Thank you, Leah!
10-30-26
Great customer service. We order from this company often. Landy is the person that handles our orders for our church and is always very helpful and timely.
10-30-26
Rachel was a big help in getting our pins made. She helped me with the layout and made sure I had all my questions answered. Her follow up is excellent. Will use GS-JJ again!
10-29-26
Excellent customer service! The pin turned out exactly how I wanted it, and I couldn’t be happier with the result! Adella was incredibly helpful throughout the entire process, always providing outstanding support and making sure everything went smoothly. She even went above and beyond to ensure my pin arrived right on time! Everything was perfect from start to finish. Highly recommend!
Custom Baseball Pins Made Simple — Just 3 Easy Steps
Share Your Concept or Sketch
Tell us what you're picturing — our design team offers free creative guidance to bring your baseball pin ideas to life.
Get Your 2D Proof Within 12 Hours
Free artwork and unlimited revisions come standard with every order, all managed by our seasoned design professionals.
See It In Realistic 3D Before Production
Your custom baseball pins will match your final 3D preview with up to 99% accuracy — what you approve is exactly what you get.
Why Pick CustomPins.Ca for Your Baseball Pins?
Two Decades of Happy Customers
We've been making custom pins for over 20 years. Getting every order right and every customer happy is still what matters most to us.
24/7 Live Chat Support
Our live chat is always on with real people standing by. Whether it's design questions, pricing details, or order updates, you'll get a real answer right away.
Fast & Free Shipping
We keep production moving quickly and cover the shipping cost — once you approve your design, your baseball pins go straight into production with no extra delivery fees.